Heh, things are funny when you go back to older threads. Apparently in 4 months you can go from a staunch supporter of the venerable MP3 format to moving on to AAC and never looking back.
Anyway, I realized I never responded regarding the album vs. individual song thing. I too rip full albums, but there are very few artists I listen to that actually make full albums that are any good. I find myself eventually marking many of the songs 1 or 2 starts so I know to uncheck them in iTunes so they don't sync in the future.
I still try to buy full albums and rip them, but I have bought the occasional song off of iTunes (and then stripped them of the DRM).
The timing makes me smile. Your post here and Que's post on hating the digitalization of music "sync up" to what I did yesterday for my mom. Months ago, she mentioned that she wanted to find a song from Leo Marini, a Latin American singer from 50-60 years ago. She said it was special to her and my dad, but couldn't remember the name. Yesterday the topic came up again, and it prompted me to try to help her find it. After some searching, I came up with
this page at Amazon. It lets you play samples of all his music in succession, without even having to press a button to advance (perfect for my tech-challenged mom). So I set it up and let her listen. Turns out to be #31 on that list, which belongs to
this album.
So I tell her we can order the CD. She likes to play CDs in this little Bose thing she's had forever. I've had a hard time teaching her all about the thousands of songs I put on her PC when I set it up for her years ago. Like I said, tech-challenged. She hands me a credit card, and I go buy the thing . . . no CD. Apparently, it's out of print, so the
only way to get this album is to
buy the MP3s. I tell her that I've never done that before, and that it would take me a few minutes to figure it all out, but that if she wants the album, it's the only way. She wants it. The process was painless, as Amazon usually is. Get their downloader, click on the "Buy MP3 album" button, wait for it all to come down. It goes into the 'My Music' folder, and gets added to Windows Media Player behind the scenes. Bring up WMP, find it, play it. Sounds amazing for the age of the music. While she's listening, I dump the album into a memory card, take it to my PC and burn her a CD. Listening to the tracks on Winamp, I see that they are VBR, ranging from 192-320 kbps except during gaps. So these are top-quality MP3s, not some schlock.
Here's one case at least where I'm glad things are the way they are. It may be easy to de-personalize music and the music experience, but it's also so much easier to find, sort, pinpoint and get stuff--on the spot. With old-style trial-and-error, and the physical media unavailable anyway, she never would have found what she wanted.