One day when I was 7, my mom, brother and I went to the video store and rented a movie. Afterward, we stopped by another store and someone accidentally left a door unlocked. While we were in the store, someone stole the VHS tape from the car, but took nothing else. We had to pay like $100 to replace the tape and never ended up seeing the movie. We finally did see the movie a few years later. It was terrible. I can't believe we even rented it, let alone had to pay $100 to replace it.
The movie was The Stuff.