Right now the game is on sale on Impluse for about $24 ($20 if you have that 2009 survey coupon), so I finally picked it up and gave it a go.
So... really? I have a hard time believing this is one of the most immersive games ever. I suppose I should start with the qualifier that I played through on hard, which may have been a mistake. But, after the tutorial the game recommended I do it, so I went with it.
Far too many times in the game, I was forced to use trial and error in order to get through the tough areas and it was just frustrating as hell. Several times, it seemed like the game expected me to be able to just know when there was a guy in a blind corner, a blind corner was being covered by another blind corner, able to dodge a constant barrage or grenades, or survive an encounter with 20+ enemies. Probably the worst part is that I'm pretty sure enemies endlessly respawned unless you pushed forward. So, you couldn't expect to clear an area and move up. Instead, you had to take the five second opportunity in between kills to move to the next area. While I suppose this is supposed to keep things intense, it doesn't help when you allies are worthless when it comes to moving forward and always wait for you to take the lead, essentially without their cover. To make it worse, they can't provide cover fire for shit. So, that leads to the blind corner problem. This was also a problem when you were expected to survive through disgustingly lopsided odds as you more or less became a one many army while your buddies just hung back. For a game that was sort of pushing reality, it relied too much on Black Hawk Down situations. Ultimately, I felt like the game was being cheap rather than just hard and the constant deaths in some of the areas pulled me out the action far too often.
That said, I think the game was worth seeing and it probably would have been much better if I was just able to enjoy the ride on normal difficulty. I really enjoyed the first half of the sniper levels and some of the more sprawling battles. I was also really impressed with the air vehicle level because it pulled off this level of detachment from the combat situation that was just interesting.
So yeah, that's my late take on the deal. Good game, could be really good, but not quite super best.