Gametrailers.com Review - they score it lower than seems logical. They don't like the story all that much, but I'm not getting that from most fans, so take that as you will, and all the video just looks absolutely fucking amazing. Jeez. It just looks so good. I can't wait.
That review actually sounds so glowing most of the time, until they throw in the one-liners without much explanations -- such as "the game's not balanced enough b/c the hero's too powerful in combat," "the game is straightforward with some cliches", and at the end the "still status quo - they played it safe."
How'd they play it safe?
--They fixed the combat system.
--The hero's not a weakling.
--The game's not cryptic in its storytelling
Playing it safe would've been not doing the three mentioned things above and sticking to the usual three SH staples of wonky combat system, lead character's a loser, and a cryptic as hell storyline.
If he wants something that's going to be revolutionary in the survival-horror/thriller genre (given Remedy's past, I have this funny feeling it will be from everything I read about it so far), tell him to wait for Alan Wake -- which sounds like what AITD 2008 could've and should've been.