No... I am with Valve on this one.
In countries like India, Thailand, Pakistan etc., the average income of a person is about $200. In Thailand you can actually live very comfortably on a lower income level because things are far cheaper there, but for the average person, paying hundreds of dollar for an operating system, or $50 for a video game, is totally out of the question.
So what happens where there is a huge demand for a commodity that is priced at the levels of a luxury good, yet is cheap to replicate?
Yes you got it, bootlegs.
Five years ago, it was easy to walk into a mall in Thailand or India and pay 50 cents to a dollar for a piece of software that would cost you much more by legal means. And no, it wasn't just because people simply wouldn't pay for a genuine product, but rather more because it was out of their means.
As a kid I remember coming to Pakistan and finding used American computer games being sold for half their retail price, and being sold very quickly.
So when these big software companies approached governments about clamping on piracy, they realized that they had to offer the public an alternative.
Today you can Windows here for $50 and games like Far Cry or the Oranage Box made in India or Thailand etc. for $15. Those games are sold with fine print on the box stating the game is for installation on local machines only, and not for export under any circumstances.
This is really beneficial to people in his part of the world, where $15 or a thousand rupees would be enough to buy food for half a week.
I also completely agree with region codes.
The fact is that the UK has its taxes and that shoots the prices up. It isn't Sony's fault that the PS3 costs ridiculously amounts of money in the UK. Nor is it able to lower the price because of the high cost in production thanks to the blu-ray drive.
If everyone in the UK started buying PS3s from America without worry of region code restrictions, a lot of people in Europe would be out of work.
Shitty Valve deactivates the keys, though. They paid for the game and got the game. They even went overseas to get a good deal. Dont like it? Tell the retailers not to ship it overseas. Or...you know, WARN people ahead of time that this will happen.
Well it says very clearly on the boxes that the games aren't for use outside of the countries where they were manufactured. The retailers know this.