Hmmmm.....interesting how things change.
To sum it up after the guy posted his story it hit the Digg.com front page. Someone found out the kid with the Xbox's Live! name and an IRC room was set up with the goal of tracking this kid down (I checked it out and there were hundreds of people in there if not more). Someone tracked down his youtube account and it snowballed from there. Within a few hours they had the kid's myspace, email, home address, landlord's information, his girlfriend's email, his phone numbers, and pretty much anything else you can think of. He's getting harassed on the phone and through the internet, but still claims he bought the xbox off of someone else. Eventually, that turns out to be true and both guys are "busted" in that they give the xbox back to the original owner because they know there's no way they're getting away from all the attention unless they do. Problem solved.
Or is it? I don't find what actually happens here all that interesting on it's own. I find the mob mentality to be whats; interesting here. Think about it; the chain of evidence was pretty weak, but it was also broken at at least one point. They had the kid's xbox live account, found his youtube account, and then gathered all the information from that and his myspace. He always claimed it wasn't him in the picture from the pawn shop, but every single internet detective 'knew better'. In fact, it wasn't him.
And that's the problem, the mob discounted what didn't justify it's actions. The full power of anominity and easily accessed information was unleashed on a petty theif. Well, actually, it was unleashed on a kid who had the misfortion of buying an xbox from a petty thief.
Don't get me wrong, the outcome was good, but this all could have very easily been a huge fuck up and the wrong family could very easily have been harassed. It's not that the mob wasn't aware of this, it's that they were too busy patting themselves on the back and thinking about how great it would be to be internet vigilantes to pay heed to the voice of reason in their own heads. That aspect scares me a bit more than the thought of having my goods ripped off.