They really fubar'd the *D-pad* on the controller. The rest of is still my personal favorite, with the Sony DS2 following, because I prefer the flipped positions of the left stick and D-pad, plus the sweet analog triggers on the 360 pad. I have no experience with with the DS3 pad, so if I ever get one, all that may change. It would depend on any perceived improvements offsetting pain in my thumb joint again (from having to reach low all the time for the left stick). I'm less confident that the sixaxis would change my mind.