I never beat Max Payne 1, but bought Max Payne 2, and never beat it either. Both awesome games, but I never beat them. I should do that.
I'm still using the mousepad that came with the first game. Not that I want a ton of random game mousepads, but it would be cool if more games did it (even if part of a collector's edition). It's the one pack-in I've gotten the most use out of by far, and it was completely free with a great game I was gonna buy anyway.